In a move that stirred debate across the league, Detroit Lions GM Brad Holmes orchestrated a bold trade in the third round of the 2025 NFL Draft, leaping 32 spots to select Arkansas wideout Isaac TeSlaa. While TeSlaa boasts undeniable athletic upside, the Lions’ decision to part with significant draft capital has sparked criticism, especially considering the availability of Stanford receiver Elic Ayomanor—a more polished and NFL-ready prospect. Holmes’ aggressive approach may ultimately be remembered not for ambition, but for overlooking a more immediate contributor.
Ayomanor, a standout at Stanford, fit Detroit’s system with uncanny precision. He brought legitimate experience as an X-receiver, complemented by elite run-blocking abilities and a reputation for intelligence and toughness. Analysts projected Ayomanor as a third-round talent, and his slide to pick No. 136 made him a glaring bargain. Compared to TeSlaa, who was ranked far lower among wideouts, Ayomanor offered a more complete package—ready to align with Amon-Ra St. Brown and support Jameson Williams in Detroit’s evolving receiving corps.
NFL Draft expert Dane Brugler ranked Ayomanor 11th among wide receivers, well ahead of TeSlaa, who came in at 24th with a late-round projection. Brugler noted Ayomanor’s rare blend of size, control, and competitive drive, praising his potential to become a physical matchup nightmare. While he remains a raw talent in need of refinement, his value at No. 102 would have allowed the Lions to preserve future picks and still secure a strong offensive weapon.
The steep cost of acquiring TeSlaa—surrendering pick No. 102 and two 2026 third-rounders—adds salt to the wound. The Lions essentially paid a premium for a high-upside project when a proven, scheme-fit receiver was already within reach. Should Ayomanor emerge as a more productive player, this trade may be remembered as Holmes’ most regrettable miscalculation since assuming leadership.
Despite Holmes’ largely successful draft track record, this decision could tarnish his legacy if TeSlaa fails to meet expectations. Detroit’s gamble on athleticism over reliability may haunt the franchise, especially if Ayomanor blossoms elsewhere. In a draft shaped by opportunity, the Lions’ front office may have fumbled a rare chance to solidify its receiving depth without sacrificing the future.