What makes Jake McCabe so valuable to the Maple Leafs?
Originally posted in NHL Trade Talk | By Old Prof | Last updated: 5/20/24.
Jake McCabe has emerged as an invaluable contributor to the Toronto Maple Leafs, receiving high acclaim from teammates and coaches for his numerous efforts. Ryan Reaves summed up McCabe’s worth, labeling him as his favorite defenseman in the league owing to his versatility:
As Reaves observed, “He does a little bit of everything.” He has great poise with the puck and breaks out well. He plays very physically. Blocks shots. He also contributes some offense. He’s like a unicorn in the league—just a guy who does everything really well.”
McCabe Handles the Toughest Matchups for the Maple Leafs
One of the most important variables influencing McCabe’s worth is his ability to handle difficult matchups, particularly in high-pressure situations such as the playoffs. In 2023, McCabe faced the harsh realities of playoff hockey, finishing with a minus-7 rating. However, he used this experience to fuel his development. Between seasons, he spoke with then-Maple Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe and promised to be more prepared for the rigours of postseason competition. In 2024, his performance showed this dedication, concluding with a plus-minus rating and exhibiting his improvement and flexibility.
As McCabe’s former head coach, Keefe emphasized his rising confidence and leadership. He stated, “He really feels like a significant part of our group now, which he definitely is. As a result, his leadership has improved significantly, as has his overall confidence. McCabe’s expanded role as a leader has been critical to the team’s dynamic, anchoring the defense and mentoring younger players.
McCabe is on a great, team-friendly contract.
Furthermore, McCabe’s economic contribution to the squad is significant. With the Chicago Blackhawks keeping half of his salary, McCabe will have a cap charge of under $2 million for the Maple Leafs in 2024-25. This cap-friendly contract is especially beneficial given McCabe’s on-ice accomplishments. The 30-year-old defenseman is coming off a career-best season with eight goals, 28 points, and a plus-20 rating, demonstrating that he is holding his own and growing with age and increasing responsibilities.
As the offseason approaches, Maple Leafs management is considering whether to extend McCabe when the option becomes available on July 1. It would seem obvious to do so. Given his critical role and ongoing development, extending McCabe might be a sensible move to strengthen the Leafs’ defense in the future.
